Private Law

Two Worlds Collide? Exploring the Role and Significance of tikanga Māori in Smith v Fonterra Co-Operative Group Ltd [2024] NZSC 5

Abstract This case note examines the New Zealand Supreme Court decision in Smith v Fonterra Co-Operative Group Ltd NZSC 5. It explores the broader relationship between tikanga Māori and common law...

A Comparative Analysis of Milieudefensie through the Lens of the Common Law: Could Companies be Negligent Under English Tort for Producing Climate Change-Causing Emissions?

In May 2021, the Dutch court of first instance in Milieudefensie v Royal Dutch Shell established a new private law obligation for a key carbon emitter: it must, through corporate policy, remove or...

The Greenwashing of Anti-greenwashing Legislation: Is Existing Regulation in the UK Adequate in Tackling Greenwashing by Corporations?

Greenwashing is defined as the behaviour of an organisation in portraying that they are doing more to protect the environment than they are in reality. Given the growing awareness surrounding climate...

What is the Point of Equality? Revisiting the Test in A Local Authority v JB

In a previous case note dated 6th March 2023, Mr Qu contended that the Supreme Court’s reformulation of the test for capacity to engage in sexual relations in A Local Authority v JB introduces a...

Shifting the Foundations of Fiduciary Liability: How Target Holdings and AIB Group Reconstructed the Doctrine of Equitable Compensation

The central question answered in Target Holdings v Redferns was whether, in the event of a breach, a trustee should only be personally liable for losses to the trust fund in fact caused by their...

How Can the Law Address the Problems that Arise from the Unethical Use of NDAs in the Workplace?

Introduction The #MeToo movement, Presidents Club Dinner, Zelda Perkins case, and other investigations involving high-profile figures have revealed the unethical use of non-disclosure agreements...

Algorithmic Creativity: How Should the UK Copyright Regime Accommodate Autonomous AI-generated Works?

Introduction From driverless cars and genetic programming to 3D printing and surgical robots, artificial intelligence (AI) has permeated our lives in extensive ways and is emerging as one of the most...

Equity or Equality before the law? What A Local Authority v JB means for Persons who are Unable to Understand what Sexual Consent is

On 24th November 2021, JB, a 38-year-old man, had his private life laid out before strangers in a courtroom, ordered to have 24-hour supervision of his interaction with people and banned from pursuing...

Are Smart Contracts Smart Enough? An Analysis through, and of, Good Faith and Freedom of Contract

ABSTRACT Contract law is rapidly evolving in synergy with new technologies. Concurrently, age-old debates remain unsolved: the desire to infuse an overt doctrine of good faith continues to clash with...

Re-examining lawful act duress: Pakistan International v Times Travel

The persistent difficulty bedevilling the doctrine of economic duress is how to draw the line between legitimate and illegitimate economic pressure. Pakistan International Airline Corporation v...

Spot the moderator in the crowd: An examination of the feasibility of a user-led moderation model in tackling disinformation on platforms

This article examines the feasibility of a user-led moderation model (hereafter referred to as the ‘Model’) in tackling disinformation on platforms, and how it can be augmented to become the...

Protecting Human Rights through Tort Law – Lessons Learned from the American ‘Alien Tort Statute’

Introduction In October 2021, Justice Secretary Dominic Raab spoke of his (and his party’s) dissatisfaction with the state of human rights law in the UK, claiming that it was open to abuse by...

Lloyd v Google on Data Privacy Class Actions: Beginning of the End, End of the Beginning?

In 2021, the UK Supreme Court delivered a landmark judgment in Lloyd v Google LLC (‘Lloyd’), which concerns a claim issued by an individual on behalf of all of England and Wales’ iPhone users against...

The Golden Mean: How the English Judiciary Failed to Balance Formalist and Realist Jurisprudence in the Development of Privacy Law

Abstract This article examines the relative roles of legal formalism and legal realism in the development of the English law of torts, with particular reference to the evolution of privacy protections...

Rethinking ‘Family’ in Family Law: Form-based, Function-based and Choice-based Frameworks

1. Introduction The conjugal family, limited to exclusive bonds of marriage and parenthood, has consistently served as the primary norm underpinning family law in many jurisdictions, including England...

Companies and Tax Avoidance: Is It Really Their Sole Duty to Maximise Shareholder Profits?

The purpose of this article is to analyse the relationship between companies and tax avoidance, focusing on the ongoing discussion of whether companies’ sole duty is to maximise shareholder profits...

Enrichment ‘at the expense of’: A critical analysis of the test of unjust enrichment

Abstract The law of unjust enrichment, despite being a foundation of private law, has been subject to much debate regarding its exact scope. A product of this discourse has been the emergence of new...

Mediation in the Modern Legal Practice: An Overlooked Money-Maker?

Measures aimed at popularising mediation often exclusively focus on how the process advantages disputants. In doing so, such measures miss out on addressing the interests of an equally important...

The Curious Case of Loot Boxes: Gaming or Gambling?

Abstract Changes to the UK’s Gambling Act 2005 have been set in motion amidst concerns over increased spending on loot boxes prompted by the COVID-19 pandemic and recent studies demonstrating the...

Fine margins: Examining the minority-majority divide in Enka v Chubb

Abstract The question of how to determine the law of the arbitration agreement has long been a hotly debated topic in the field of international commercial arbitration. While this contentious issue...

The Unification of Private Law in Times of COVID-19

Abstract This article tests the role of three UNIDROIT instruments in reducing the uncertainty caused by the COVID-19 pandemic. First, we cover force majeure and hardship under the...

Individualisation in Contractual Interpretation

Introduction The area of contract interpretation has been heavily discussed in light of the Court’s seemingly conflicting case law on the shift towards the contextual approach. In particular...

Unintentional Transmission of Disease Revisited – a Tort Law Perspective on COVID-19

Introduction Can individuals infected with COVID-19 sue those who unintentionally transmitted the novel coronavirus to them? This article explores the effectiveness of using the tort of negligence as...

A Bank’s Liability for a Director’s Misappropriation of Funds: Singularis Holdings Limited (in liq) v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Ltd

Introduction In the recent decision of Singularis Holdings Limited (in liq) v Daiwa Capital Markets Europe Ltd,1 the Supreme Court affirmed a bank’s liability to a corporate customer for the...

Material contribution: bridging the evidentiary gap

To right a private wrong, causation is generally established between the tortfeasor’s negligent act and claimant’s injury. However, on occasion, the evidence will be such that a causal...

Darnley v Croydon Health Service NHS Trust: delineating duty and breach

Case Note: Darnley v Croydon Health Service NHS Trust  UKSC 50, 3 WLR 1153 A. Introduction1 Darnley v Croydon Health Service NHS Trust2 (‘Darnley‘) deals with the...

Hoffmann vs Sumption – Reconciling the battle on contractual interpretation?

Introduction What is more exciting than a legal tirade between two of the most prominent English judges? Contractual interpretation is the bread-and-butter work of the commercial courts. Whilst it...

Creating easements with ease: Re Ellenborough Park test revisited

Case note: Regency Villas Title Ltd v Diamond Resorts (Europe) Ltd  UKSC 57 A. Introduction The law of easement, a seemingly dry and technical aspect of land law, has been rejuvenated in the...

English Choice of Law in Contract Under the Rome I Regime: Is Flexibility Giving Way to Predictability?

The Rome I Regulation (593/2008/EC) is the EU regulation which governs the choice of law applicable to contractual obligations in civil and commercial matters. It replaces the 1980 Rome Convention and...

The Undisclosed Principal: Limiting Liability for Negligent Misrepresentations

Banca Nazionale del Lavoro SPA v Playboy Club London Limited and others  UKSC 43 concerns a claim for pure economic loss due to a negligent misrepresentation. It sets a precedent for cases that...

Employees or Independent Contractors: What Defines a “Worker”?

Pimlico Plumbers Limited v Smith  UKSC 29 deals with several important issues concerning an intermediate category of working people falling between an “employee” under a contract of...

What can legal academics add to the debate about private equity?

Dear Editor,  In December 2015, Unite — Britain’s largest trade union — called on the UK government to investigate the ‘secretive machinations of private equity...